Early this morning after I pushed Paul to resonate with me about how awesome it to snuggle close and warm all night long, I was reminded that he is the best boyfriend ever.
I was hoping he would say something like “That was lovely night, my darling” or “I feel so close to you” or some such fantasy thing - but all he as saying when I asked, “Did you have a good night?” was “U
mm-hm”.
And when I probed further he said, “I preferred the snuggling in the morning to being entwined in the middle of the night.”
Unsatisfied, I continued to try to draw something warm and toasty out of him “… so wasn’t it a little bit special? Can you tell me what it meant to you? I just want to be able to share the same meaning…”
And as I’m trying this or that tactic to get the connection I want, I’m realizing,
1. He’ doesn’t want to give me the warm fuzzy
2. This is the kind of stuff men hate about women
3. But I can’t let it go because I’m hormonal and I want what I want
So as it becomes increasingly clear that he either can’t or won’t resonate warmth and closeness with me, I fling myself over an opposite pillow and allow all my bones to melt like something in a hot car, staring dejectedly away from him into the colorless middle distance.
Now, at this point, what other boyfriend would not have just gotten dressed and left an academy award on the bureau on his way out?
But Paul stays and gently responds to my exaggerated posture of despair. ”I can see that what you wanted was resonance and all I was giving you analysis. I’m sorry. I didn’t intend to upset you.”
Now, at this point, what girlfriend would not have thanked her lucky stars, kissed him fondly and sent him on his way?
But I had to pick at him some more. ”It doesn’t matter what you intended,” I said. “Do you realize that you are undermining your apology by talking about what your intent was? As if somehow you aren’t responsible because you didn’t mean it?”
We then proceded to have a discussion about the role of intent in an apology. He said that he used intent to evaluate how much offense he should take. I said that I consider intent as well, but it doesn’t undo the damage. It doesn’t erase the impact. If you really want someone to know you are sorry, you will say you are sorry and leave it at that.
(Please note, during this discussion, I realize that, while I’m essentially right, I’m pushing it, and I think that at any moment I’m going to exasperate him into leaving.)
He’s says there’s a big difference between an act that intended harm (I’m going to get there late on purpose), caused harm through neglect (I lost track of time), or the harm was cause outside of anyone’s control (traffic was unexpectedly bad).
I agreed that intent has bearing on how offended we might get, but still, intent doesn’t mitigate damage. If I wanted to start a meeting on time and you are 20 minutes late, regardless of your intent, it’s still 20 lost minutes. The apology is primarily about regret for the damages.
Now, any other boyfriend would have argued his point until we were screaming at eachother and slamming doors.
But Paul, the best boyfriend ever, said, “Hmmm. I’ll have to consider this.”
(Please note, this is the best outcome a girl could hope for. We don’t really care all that much whether we’re right or not, we care more about whether we are connected or not. [Look for a long luscious blog post about this soon] And his willingness to consider my point of view feels like a big DING DING DING on the connection meter.)
Now, any other boyfriend would have gone off about his business and never brought it up again.
But a couple hours later he calls and thanks me for being so helpful.
(Please note, he THANKED me for being HELPFUL)
He said that he had done something or other that he needed to make right about some logistics with his ex-wife. He said he apologized to her without editorializing about his intent, and she seemed moved and pleased.
So, now, don’t I have me the best boyfriend ever? And doesn’t his ex-wife have a great ex-husband?
And, really, it’s me who is saying she is sorry, by writing the post. Sorry that I can be so pushy and nit picky and nitty gritty, parsing every little interaction.
Yet again, I am amazed and humbled that I’m so lucky that I get to love a geek.